If I want to take a bus from my apartment in the Greenpoint section
of Brooklyn to downtown Brooklyn, a few miles away, I catch the B61
at the corner of Greenpoint Avenue and McGuinness Boulevard. Greenpoint
has been a predominantly Polish neighborhood since World War II, when
Polish immigrants began arriving by the thousands, displacing the Germans
and Irish, who previously had helped make Greenpoint into a major shipyard
(the fabled iron-clad Monitor of Civil War fame was built in
Greenpoint). On the streets of Greenpoint, you hear more Polish spoken
than English, and Polish signs line the main shopping street, Manhattan
Avenue—although, if you look closely, you'll see a scattering
of retail signs partially in Arabic, and many of the small corner grocery
stores are owned by Arabs.
After the bus picks me up, it passes out of Greenpoint and into an
Italian neighborhood (birthplace of Henry Miller), then a Puerto Rican
neighborhood, then a neighborhood with one of the largest concentrations
of Hasidic Jews in the United States, then an African-American neighborhood
dominated by public housing tenements fronted by a police station, and
finally a middle-class African-American neighborhood (where Spike Lee
grew up and his father still lives) before reaching downtown Brooklyn.
This, of course, is only a small cross-section of Brooklyn as it radiates
out from downtown like a crooked spoke traced along a single bus route.
(In reality, downtown Brooklyn—like downtown Los Angeles—is
more of a non-center.) None of the neighborhoods the B61 travels through
are completely distinct, and they all seep into and directly connect
with one another.
Brooklyn and New York City make immediately visible what is true throughout
the United States and the rest of the world—that demographics
and sociology need to be a kind of poetics if they hope to more fully
account for quickly shifting populations and complex interactions between
cultures. Similarly, if poetics isn't going to retreat into a universalist
aestheticism and implicit or explicit ethnocentrism, then it needs to
be in at least partial dialogue with contemporary sociology and ethnography.
All too often, postmodernism is implicit ethnocentrism by another name,
just as explicit ethnocentrism is what cultural conservatives want to
preserve in the name of traditional canons, national literatures, and
English-only initiatives.
Mark Nowak's book Revenants is one of the best recent examples
of a poetry engaged with issues of context, ethnography, and cultural
history. Likewise, the journal he edits, Xcp: Cross-Cultural Poetics,
is among the most intellectually substantive and progressive literary
magazines published today. Xcp includes poetry and fiction, essays
and book reviews, all with an interest in the relations between different
cultures within and outside of the United States. Scholarly, multicultural
in a dialogical way, and smartly mixing various aesthetic forms and
styles (with an emphasis on the avant-garde), Xcp creates an
inclusive terrain for rethinking contemporary poetics and its relation
to historiography, anthropology, and ethnography—and vice versa.
The idea of relation cannot be raised without an accompanying understanding
of place. Similarly, to begin to know the place in which one lives—no
matter how local and apparently homogeneous—is to begin to form
an awareness of relations with other places. This is one of the starting
points for Revenants, the title of which refers to someone returning
after a long absence. Nowak isn't afraid to investigate concepts that
have fallen into disrepute in the postmodern era: notably tradition,
custom, and, to a certain extent, history. But the opening series of
poems, "The Pain-Dance Begins," immediately signals that this return
isn't one of nostalgia, nor is it a quest for a lost or pure origin.
Tradition is not addressed in these poems with the sole hope of reviving
the past. Instead, the poems reveal that many important customs within
local communities have been forgotten, or altered by contemporary culture.
At the same time, while the transmission of traditions has the potential
to create alternatives to a standardizing Western consumer culture,
they can never be isolated from it.
In "The Pain-Dance Begins," Nowak outlines a kind of metaphysical ethnography.
Each of the poems is partially oriented around a single Polish word
(sometimes it serves as the title of the poem), which are frequently
abstract in nature, even when referring to concrete objects: "oczekiwanie—anticipation,
expectation"; "skutek—consequence"; zboze—corn,
grain of all types" (an alphabetized glossary of Polish words is included
in the back of the book). The poems, too, are frequently abstract and
metaphysical in their approach, while they weave in references to the
everyday world. All myths, it turns out, have social and historical
roots. In fact, the best poems in "The Pain-Dance Begins" create a balance
between mythmaking and historiography. Take, for instance, the first
half of an untitled poem:
Zdarzenie [incident, occurrence], what if the breath anyone is about
to breathe is
not here?
A child bell-caster, in from the provinces,
watches a man in blue swim trunks he might have been
many years from now, in a specific location,
some distance south of the waters of Hudson Bay.
By the same token that Adam is not a man (in Hebrew …
the moon shines
half-way around the world,
a walleye hits a Red Devil spoon in the waters of Lake Mille Lacs.
In lines that are semantically and rhythmically dense and layered while
also expansive, Nowak combines his interest in symbol and metaphor (the
"child bell-caster" here and elsewhere in the book seems to allude to
Andrei Tarkovski's representation of the artist as a young bell-maker
in his film Andrei Rublev); allegory (the unfolding of meaning
in time, as in "a man … he might have been many years from now");
specific location (the Hudson Bay and Lake Mille Lacs); and everyday
objects, with their corporate inflection (the "Red Devil spoon" fishing
lure).
As the above passage hints at, the poems in the first section of Revenants
are suffused with a religious sensibility that is combined with Nowak's
aim to precisely record the subject's immersion in time and place. This
recording becomes much more specific in the second and third sections
of Revenants. Here, Nowak utilizes contemporary ethnographic
methods to document particular customs and locations within Polish communities.
Nowak makes clear that these are specific ethnic groups by focusing
on their internal and external representations. There's an effort to
move away from ethnic essentialisms—"We speak of identity w/ split
tongues"—while also addressing these essentialisms from both within
and outside of the Polish communities he describes. For instance, the
poem "Zwyczaj [Custom]" focuses on Polish cooking:
Someone asks:
How many pierogi
to re-roof
a heritage?
"I heard that [my matka (mother) says]
once before."
A note to the poem reveals that it's almost entirely collaged from
three different sources. The first consists of an interview conducted
by Nowak and printed in bold. The second is an article published in
the journal New York Folklore and written by two researchers
studying baking practices in a small Polish community in western New
York. The third is a theoretical text on ethnographic method. While
the poem commences with the language of ethnic essentialism quoted above,
the perspectives and conceptual framework set up by the three sources
instead document "social life // as constituted by ongoing, fluid processes."
And while the cooking of pierogi is depicted in the poem as the practice
of a particular ethnic group, the threat this social, economic, and
spiritual activity faces from pre-packaged commercial products connects
it with a broader sense of diversity that counteracts the homogenizing
tendencies of globalized Western culture.
The final section of the book is in many ways its best. Building on
the poetic ethnography of the previous poem, "Zwyczaj," "'Back
Me Up'" reproduces photographs Nowak took mostly of bars—but also
restaurants and a bowling alley—on the Polish East Side of Buffalo,
N.Y., and juxtaposes them on facing pages with poems incorporating snippets
of another interview conducted by the author as well as published diary
excerpts from 1917-18. Here, all the elements in Nowak's book come together.
The various documentary methods and materials presented throughout Revenants
are further multiplied as immediacy and distance, past and present,
oral and written texts, photographs and memories mix together, separate,
and then mix again. In "'Back Me Up,'" local and microhistories seek
to find their own voices within a consumer culture that drowns out what
it can't appropriate and cash in on. Many of the bars in the photos
are boarded up or clearly barely getting by. But one of the points of
the interview woven into the poem—and one of the points of the
book as a whole—is that local communities have their own economies
of survival and generosity. "'alternate // 'social //
'representations" quotes Nowak in "'Back Me Up.'" This work
is much needed at this particular historical moment. In contributing
its small, carefully documented part, Revenants deserves to be
read large. •
Alan Gilbert's reviews and essays have appeared in artbyte,
Publishers Weekly, and Rain Taxi.