|
Loving
Graham Greene
Gloria Emerson
Random House, $22.05
(cloth)
An
American Outrage
G. K. Wuori
Algonquin $22.05 (cloth)
by Jennifer Howard
Look for the road to hell and you find it paved with good
intentions. Look harder, and you begin to wonder: maybe the desire to
do goodto live right by oneself and ones fellowscan
become hell itself.
Molly Benson, prime mover of Gloria Emersons novel
Loving Graham Greene, knows nothing but good intentions. In trying
to act on them, she creates unanticipated torments, some petty and some
parlous, for people she wants to help. Married, childless, in her forties,
Molly runs a small foundation out of her living room in Princeton, N.J.
To the dismay of her friends, mother, and stockbroker, she cant
give her inherited money away fast enough to causes that irk the US
government: "money for medicines in Cuba, money for the Sandinista
tuberculosis clinics in Nicaragua, money for the rebel hospitals in
El Salvador, money for Palestinians in Gaza, and so forth." Molly
shares her taste for hot zones with her creator; Emerson won the National
Book Award in 1978 for Winners & Losers, a study of the effects
of the Vietnam War on Americans, and has spent time in and written about
El Salvador, Gaza, and Algeriaall of which figure, in one way
or another, in this novel.
Every angel of mercy needs a god to pray to; Mollys
is a writer:
Once, Molly tried to explain her devotion to Graham
Greene to her mother. "He took sides," she said. "He
was fearless." No one who heard this, and there were plenty of
them, remembered or cared what all the sides once were but he always
had. What he found indecent was the injustice that the poor of the
world were in the habit of enduring, and the arrogance of the dictators
and the bloated malevolent governments, so often propped up and pampered
by the United States.
During his last years, Molly adopted Greene as a sort
of pet project, barraging him with letters and clippings. On a trip
to Antibes, where he kept a home, Molly encountered Greene himself and
spent an afternoon making small-talk, an event she cherishes out of
all proportion to its significance.
Molly also worships the memory of her brother, Harry,
a journalist who shared her altruistic compulsions and was killed "in
a small, ravaged country where Spanish was spoken." She needs to
believe he was gunned down on purpose by a soldier; other journalists
hint at something more useless and random, a heart attack at the wheel,
a checkpoint fatally ignored. Harry understood why Molly "did not
like money or trust its power"; he understood her "need to
distance herself from a culture she abhorred, a society deformed and
contaminated by money, sickening itself, insatiable and pathetic. No
one could repudiate this except by abnegation, by sharing, and by a
strict refusal to consume or to yield to any frivolity."
And yet Molly undertakes her good deeds in a whimsicalone
could say frivolousspirit, the moral equivalent of shopping sprees.
From a catalog she orders "an inexpensive summer skirt" for
a nun who, "unaccustomed to nice surprises," runs a feeding
station in Central America. Undone by a photo of two murdered Salvadoran
women, Molly "wanted to protest, but had only the feeblest idea
of how to avenge the deaths of the two and honor them at the same time."
She and Bertie, her childhood friend and do-good sidekick, stage an
elaborate raid on the apartment of the Salvadoran consul general in
New York: "the mission was to deface his front door with handprints
in white paint, to scare the consul general to death
. Mano
Blanco, said Molly, remembering a bright red door with huge white
hands on it, paint dripping. It was how the death squads in El Salvador
announced that an assassination had been carried out in the house."
But the consul generals door turns out to be painted an unaccomodating
beige, and the meager handprints the women plant on it might have been
left there by "capricious children." Most of Mollys
projects turn out similar successes.
The central action in Loving Graham Greene kicks
off after the writers death in 1991. As Molly grieves for him
and for Harry, civil war looms in Algeria. To ease her pain and honor
her hero, Molly conceives another of her schemes:
to lead a little delegation to Algiers in the hope of
rescuing a few writers there.... A New York committee advised her,
by mail and by telephone, that a growing number of Islamic fundamentalists
there were threatening writers and journalists opposed to them. The
committee only wanted money, but Molly thought she might locate a
few doomed men and pay for their tickets to leave the country. This
was a chance, too, to see the great colonial city the French had embraced
for 132 years and relinquished in chaos and disgrace.
See the world while saving it.
Thats not absolutely fair to a good-hearted woman.
Molly could easily be a figure of fun, an unquiet American bungling
her way into places she cant possibly understand. But Emersons
heroineand she is thatcarries intelligence and dignity with
her even as she wades into situations where her presence is worse than
useless. When she sees two men she believes innocent being hauled into
a police station in Algiers, "Molly, who passionately felt that
all decent people must interfere to save the helpless even if it put
them at risk, began hollering and running toward the group.... She was
so fast that she was even able to grab the arm of one of the prisoners,
as if to pull him free." That she only aggravates the police and
makes a bad situation worse doesnt wipe out the decency of the
impulse. She superimposes extraordinary qualities on ordinary craven
acts; she wants people to be better than they are, as well as better
off. "What made Molly certain, although she had no experience in
these matters, that the prisoners were innocent was their cringing appearance,
the disbelief on their faces. She thought guilty men would be prouder
and more defiant, carrying themselves differently to the beatings that
would come and the long hours of interrogation ahead."
In the most basic sense, Molly isnt naïve.
She has read her Algerian history; she can identify the scars of torture;
she suspects her own motives and the expeditions that are "clearly
an escape to somewhere new, with desperate people as the excuse."
She even knows that "her own version of Harrys death could
not hold up forever, however tightly she held on to it." But her
flashes of self-awareness are just that; they spark for a moment and
then go. Most of the time she runs at goals she cant quite see.
When adolescent Islamistes beat up her small party in the Casbah
of Algiers, she flails and lashes out, a tornado of useless energy:
"People came into the square, but only to watch. They found Molly
entertaining before she collapsed. She urgently wanted to oppose the
vicious boys, rather than just scream and crumple and bleed, as if something
far greater were expected of her."
To show exactly where and how Molly fails, Emerson takes
a surprising risk. Mollys third-person-limited voice fills most
of the story; but the narrative flits in and out of the consciousness
of almost everyone who deals with her, often just stopping in for a
quick thought or two: Why is this woman so weird? What does she want?
Why cant she live like normal people? When will she leave us alone?
Cant she see shes causing trouble? That the risk pays offthat
the reader can rotate smoothly through ten or twenty points of view
in one slim book and hardly register the shiftstestifies to Emersons
command of story, character and language. One catches shades of Greene
in Emersons writing, which she keeps taut and smooth and yet flexible
enough to wrap around a psychological detail or a telling moment in
a glancing phrase or twoone of the many pleasures of a nearly
perfect novel.
Loving Graham Greene is a beautifully controlled
story about a woman unable to control the consequences of her acts;
G. K. Wuoris novel, An American Outrage, lets itself go
from the beginning. Its a blowsy, folksy, tragi-comic, catch-as-catch-can
tale of lives gone off the rails in a small town in Maine. QuillifarkeagQuilli,
for shorthas few claims to fame; it "has its basic streets
and roads, its basic services. Its institutions consist of a few churches
and schools, a branch of the state university, a modest hospital, and
a good-sized potato-processing plant whose french fries you have
eaten." (It also provided the setting for Wuoris previous
book, the story collection, Nude in Tub.)
The Virgil guiding us through Quillis circles of
hell is Splotenbrun Doll, nicknamed Splotchy. (Wuori has a distracting
weakness for extravagant names).
About me, a few things ought to be said, although the
following account is not about me. That I am short, white-haired,
middle-aged (a personal definition), divorced (for now), opinionated
(thus: wordy, talky), educated, healthy, a newspaper reader, a book
reader, and a little chubby are all tags that friends might hang on
me if the question was, Who is Splotenbrun Doll?
There is another
quality, however, another tag that is now properly mine, and as I
write it here for the first time the door will open into this narrative,
the beginnings of purpose will be seen: I am the father of a killer.
Splotchy has a devil of a tale to tell, and in the tradition
of rural storytellers he takes his time telling it. What emerges, as
he wanders through Quilli history, collecting bits and pieces of it
from his fellow citizens, is this: after 26 years of seeming contentment,
town resident Ellen DeLay left her husband, Joe, and like a latter-day
eremite took up residence in a cabin in the woods, where she made a
living by dressing hunters kill. She liked to do this scantily
clothed, a habit that made cleanup easier and fueled the gossip back
in town. Faced with the evidencespousal abandonment, a life spent
half-wild and half-naked in the woods"Quilli, like any town,
never cutting with a fine knife when a dull one will do, said Ellen
went nuts."
In fact, Ellen seems to have been mostly sane, if unorthodox
and confused about the best direction to pursue in life. (In some respects
shes kin to Molly Benson.) That doesnt matter to the three
men who, out drinking beer near Ellens woods, find themselves
on the receiving end of a stray bullet fired from Ellens gun.
(Nobody is seriously hurt.) Nor does it matter to the authorities, all
women, all armed, who converge on the scene with uncertain motives and
hair-trigger dispositions. One of them, town provost Cary Anderson,
gets so itchy that she leads an assault on Ellens cabin. A personalized
version of the Ruby Ridge or Waco sieges, its over in a flash,
and Ellens dead, felled by dozens of rounds of ammunition
expelled from her oddball earthly paradise in a burst of apocalyptic
frenzy. Wilma Doll, Splotchys forty-plus daughter and Ellens
best pal, has the misfortune to be visiting Ellen during the assault.
She escapes the barrage; she vows revenge, and in good unpremeditated
time takes it.
Splotchys playing town Virgil at Wilmas request,
trying to beat fragments of memory into a narrative that sticks together
and explains something. But Wuori cant, or wont, let Splotchy
tell us certain things: why Cary "went nuts" at Ellens,
why Ellen really left Joe (just that she felt something missing, a hollowness
at the heart). Its damn near impossible to decide whether this
is deliberatea way of saying that we cant know what occupies
the minds or controls the actions of other peopleor whether Wuoris
characters leave him as baffled as they leave themselves.
Wuoris characters have farcical, even demonic namesSplotchy,
Vendrum Ponus, Fendamius "Poison" Gorelick, Spicy Pelletierand
they could lose a few aphorisms and quirks. But these people have more
than a touch of the angel and the philosopher about them, and they know
how to put deep feelings into fine words. Just because a place happens
to be lowly, small, and inconsequential, Wuori seems to be saying, doesnt
mean that hellish tragedy cant find it.
Jennifer Howard,
a contributing editor at the Washington Post Book World, recently
completed a novel. She reviewed Joan
Silber in the Summer 2000 issue and Ronan
Bennett in the October/November 1999 issue.
Originally published in the December
2000/January 2001 issue of Boston Review
|